Five council by-elections took place on Thursday, with two defences each for Labour and Reform, plus one Tory defence. The latter went to the Greens, who scored a rare gain on the back of a split in the right-wing vote. This seat was otherwise another impressive new entry for Reform who surged into second place and missed out on victory by only 34 votes.
In the other four contests it was swings and roundabouts for Reform and Labour. For the second week in a row they gained seats from each other, including a stunning gain for Labour in St Helens. Labour also technically gained ground as Reform took another seat from them in Sheffield. Reform had won one of the other council seats in this ward emphatically in May, but their lead over Labour was cut from over a thousand votes to less than 300. Labour held a seat in London on the back of the declining Green vote, while Reform held relatively easily in Newcastle.
A much better performance overall for Labour this week, with vote share up in three out of five seats. The Burnham bounce may not be huge, but it is allowing Labour to compete with Reform in a way they could not under the Starmer millstone. As things stand we are heading for a hung parliament with Labour the biggest party.
Guston, Kingsdown & St Margaret's-at-Cliffe, Dover District Council
Grn: 767 (28.8%) +2.7%
Ref: 733 (27.5%) New
Con: 456 (17.1%) -16.0%
Lab: 389 (14.6%) -9.2%
Res: 284 (10.7%) New
Ind: 35 (1.3%) New
Grn GAIN from Con
Triggered by the retirement of the Tory incumbent. The Conservatives won both seats here in the 2023 election, but lost control of the council for the first time since 2007. Labour took a very slender majority, which was lost within two years following various resignations and defections. The slip into no overall control was caused by the defection of a Labour councillor to none other than the Conservatives. Labour continue to run the council as a minority administration, despite now having less council seats than the aforementioned Tories. There were plenty of changes to the ballot paper going into Thursday's contest, with no Lib Dem or Heritage Party candidates this time, but three new entries. The appearance of Reform and Restore Britain looked set to damage the defending Tories and that proved to be the case, with the Greens taking full advantage of the split vote. It can be argued that Reform's narrow defeat - by just 34 votes - is the first real damage that Rupert Lowe's party has inflicted on his old party.
Karl - Ref GAIN ✘
Rich - Ref GAIN ✘
Throckley, Walbottle & Newburn, Newcastle City Council
Ref: 901 (39.0%) -4.8%
LDm: 670 (29.0%) +24.3%
Lab: 534 (23.1%) -5.9%
Grn: 103 (4.5%) -9.2%
Con: 101 (4.4%) -4.4%
Ref HOLD
Another week, another short-lived Reform councillor. The incumbent resigned two months after being elected on May 7, citing 'an abrupt change in her health, personal and work commitments'. That's quite a lot to change simultaneously. She had won the third seat here in May as Reform took all three of the ward's council seats following boundary changes. The ward in its previous format historically returned Labour councillors and the party was looking to regain one of those seats on Thursday. As it turned out, Labour slumped further behind as the Lib Dems surged past them into second place. A relatively easy hold for Reform.
Karl - Ref HOLD ✔
Rich - Lab GAIN ✘
Southey, Sheffield City Council
Ref: 1,133 (50.6%) +0.6%
Lab: 836 (37.3%) +12.8%
Grn: 146 (6.5%) -6.4%
Con: 69 (3.1%) -1.7%
LDm: 56 (2.5%) -2.2%
Ref GAIN from Lab
Triggered by the resignation of the Labour incumbent, who had been sitting as an independent since April of this year. It is not clear why he left the Labour party, but he chose to stand down from the council altogether as a consequence of 'personal and family commitments'. Labour numbers on Sheffield City Council have been in gradual decline since 2012, when they held 60 seats. This dropped to 25 in May, while in the same period the Green party has gone from two seats to 20. These two competing left-wing outfits are currently administering Sheffield as a coalition authority. The incumbent in this ward won easily in 2024, finishing over a thousand votes ahead of the second placed Green. Things changed dramatically here in May, when it was Reform who surged over a thousand votes in front of Labour. It wasn't quite as dramatic a victory on Thursday, with Reform's lead cut to just under 300. There was no independent or Trade Unionist candidate this time, who between them picked up almost 140 votes in May.
Karl - Ref GAIN ✔
Rich - Ref GAIN ✔
Rich - Ref GAIN ✔
Billinge & Seneley Green, St Helens Metropolitan Borough Council
Lab: 1,158 (41.4%) +18.8%
Ref: 892 (31.9%) -2.6%
Ind: 496 (17.7%) -1.5%
Grn: 106 (3.8%) -9.2%
Con: 94 (3.0%) -4.5%
Ind: 60 (2.1%) New
Lab GAIN from Ref
Another departing Reform councillor triggered this by-election after just two months in office. She cited 'personal reasons' for ending her short stint. Her party demolished Labour in St Helens on May 7, ending 16 years of outright Labour control and leaving them with just two seats. This was Reform's second by-election defence since that day, having successfully defended the Haydock ward in June. It wasn't to be this time as Labour surged in front for an impressive gain. Reform's candidate had come under fire for 'Islamophobic' and 'anti-vax' social media posts, but it is not clear if this had a major bearing on the result.
Karl - Ref HOLD ✘
Rich - Ref HOLD ✘
Trinity, Wandsworth London Borough Council
Lab: 1,558 (47.5%) +8.8%
Con: 1,431 (43.6%) +9.0%
Grn: 168 (5.1%) -10.8%
LDm: 75 (2.3%) -3.0%
Ref: 51 (1.6%) -2.6%
Lab HOLD
The resignation of the incumbent triggered this vacancy. She had been Labour's deputy group leader on the council, but there were conflicting reasons why she stood down. She claimed to have taken a 'politically restricted' job that would automatically require her to relinquish her council role, while almost simultaneously declaring that it was her pregnancy and family commitments that drove her decision. Either way, we have an intriguing contest between the red and blue half of the Uniparty. Up until this year, Wandsworth Council was controlled outright by either red or blue. On May 7, the council slipped into no overall control for the very first time, with the Conservatives taking over from Labour as a minority administration. The fairly even split of the council was reflected in this ward, which in May divided its two seats between Labour and the Tories. Once again, it was a closely fought battle between Uniparty candidates, with Labour emerging victorious. Labour appeared to benefit from a significant swing from the Greens. There was no independent or Trade Unionist candidate this time, but they only garnered a handful of votes in May.
Karl - Lab HOLD ✔
Rich - Lab HOLD ✔
Mixed results for our team this week, but it was Karl who came out on top. He cuts Richey's lead down to six.















































