We had a county-wide election this week, but it wasn't for the council. The position of Police and Crime Commissioner in Norfolk was up for grabs...
Norfolk Police and Crime Commissioner
Colin Sutton (Ref) 32,647 (26.7%) New
Matthew Taylor (Con) 18,348 (15.0%) -18.9%
Martin Schmierer (Grn) 16,907 (13.8%) -2.0%
Marcus Pearcey (Ind) 16,402 (13.4%) New
Beth Jones (Lab) 14,192 (11.6%) -23.6%
Mark Buckton (Res) 13,319 (10.9%) New
Christopher Brown (LDm) 10,499 (8.6%) -6.5%
Ref GAIN from Lab
Labour won this election in 2024, with a relatively narrow victory over the Conservatives. This time the result wasn't even close and Labour crashed to fifth. Police and Crime Commissioners are being abolished in two years time, with the responsibilities being transferred into the remit of elected mayors. This announcement last year led to a backlash from Norfolk's PCC, who quit Labour in anguish, accusing the government of a 'lack of consultation'. She continued in the role as an independent, before vacating the post last month due to a family illness. She also left her role as a district councillor (see below). There were a few new faces on the PCC ballot paper this time, all stumping up £500 for the privilege. All four parties saved their deposits last time, as it proved this time around - every single candidate surpassed the required five per cent mark in order to get their deposit back. This included Restore Britain, who were hoping for a decent result as Rupert Lowe's constituency falls entirely within the catchment area. Any hopes they may have had of denting Reform's chances were not realised, as Reform won with an impressive majority of 14,299 (compared to Labour's 1,888 majority in 2024). Reform's first ever PCC is highly respected former detective Colin Sutton, who led various high profile murder investigations during a long career. This has been a costly election to the taxpayer, with a bill of £2million that on a 17.1 per cent turnout worked out at more than £16 per vote!
Karl - Con GAIN ✘
Rich - Ref GAIN ✔
There were also eight council seats to be decided this week, all of which fell inside England and all but one sit across a central belt from Staffordshire in the west to Norfolk in the east. The only exception is a seat in the Rushmoor borough of Hampshire.
Dereham Toftwood, Breckland District Council
Con: 458 (45.8%) -1.7%
Ref: 369 (36.9%) New
Lab: 172 (17.2%) -35.3%
Con GAIN from Lab
Triggered by the resignation of the incumbent, who simultaneously vacated her post as Norfolk Police and Crime Commissioner (see above). This ward was a straight head-to-head last time between Labour and the Conservatives. Reform had won all three of the previous council by-elections held in Breckland, but their Turkish candidate could not persuade enough voters in this semi-rural ward to swing it for her party. She did however enjoy a huge swing from Labour that dumped the incumbent party in last place and delivered a Conservatives gain.
Karl - Ref GAIN ✘
Rich - Con GAIN ✔
Ramsey & Bury, Cambridgeshire County Council
Ref: 506 (29.7%) -17.3%
Ind: 417 (24.5%) New
Con: 412 (24.2%) -5.2%
LDm: 126 (7.4%) +0.6%
Grn: 123 (7.2%) +1.2%
Lab: 118 (6.9%) -4.0%
Ref HOLD
Reform gained this seat from the Conservatives in last year's local elections, but the winner recently stood down, citing 'personal circumstances'. Last year's defeated Conservative sought to get her former seat back at this by-election, but slipped to third place. She was narrowly beaten by an independent, who took a significant swing from Reform. Labour finished third here last year, but collect the wooden spoon this time around. No Burnham bounce here!
Karl - Con GAIN ✘
Rich - Ref HOLD ✔
Kidlington West, Cherwell District Council
LDm: 1,028 (58.8%) +13.7%
Ref: 331 (18.9%) -4.3%
Con: 232 (13.2%) -4.1%
Grn: 158 (9.0%) -5.4%
LDm HOLD
Triggered by the resignation of the Lib Dem incumbent, who gained this seat from the Conservatives in 2021. She resigned for 'personal reasons', primarily to spend more time with her family. The Lib Dems were very keen to hold here, as their coalition majority hung by a thread. They did so with ease, garnering three times as many votes as second placed Reform, while their coalition partners the Greens picked up the wooden spoon.
Karl - LDm HOLD ✔
Rich - LDm HOLD ✔
Old Catton, Norfolk County Council
Con: 973 (34.6%) +8.5%
Grn: 921 (32.7%) +14.0%
Ref: 561 (19.9%) -10.1%
Lab: 147 (5.2%) -10.6%
LDm: 100 (3.6%) -5.6%
Res: 98 (3.5%) New
Loon: 13 (0.5%) New
Con GAIN from Ref
Triggered by the resignation of the incumbent less than four weeks after he was elected in May, citing 'poor health'. Did he not expect to win? A very poor show that left his colleague with what turned out to be an insurmountable task of holding the seat. The former Conservative councillor selected by Reform was heavily defeated by her old party, while the Greens pushed her into third. This was the first ever local election fought in the name of Restore Britain, but it was disastrous. Their candidate pulled out shortly after the nomination papers were handed in, but it was too late to remove his name from the ballot paper. It's not going well is it, Rupert?
Karl - Grn GAIN ✘
Rich - Con GAIN ✔
Fletton & Woodston, Peterborough City Council
Grn: 664 (41.2%) +3.4%
Ref: 479 (29.7%) +2.9%
Lab: 213 (13.2%) +3.7%
Con: 208 (12.9%) -3.2%
LDm: 37 (2.3%) New
YrP: 11 (0.7%) New
Grn GAIN from Lab
As often tends to be the case with the Banana Republic of Peterborough, this by-election was mired in controversy before a single vote had been cast. Triggered by the resignation of a young native lady who was elected as a Labour councillor in the 2024 elections, she quit the party a year later after accusing her comrades of 'sustained bullying and marginalisation'. Why was she targeted? She simply called for CCTV to be installed in the city's taxis. This led to her facing accusations of 'racism' from Muslim comrades, who also tarred her family with the same brush. In resigning her seat recently, she accused the council of 'systemic cover-ups', which Labour's Muslim council leader denied. As Peterborough wards go, this one is not overtly Muslim, but it did opt for the Greens in May. An independent candidate who stood here in that election dropped out, while there was a rare outing for the Fruit and Nutters. The Corbyn shitshow finished last with just 11 votes, while the party that stole their far left thunder roared into the lead and garnered more than three times the number of votes received by Labour.
Karl - Ref GAIN ✘
Rich - Grn GAIN ✔
Wellington, Rushmoor Borough Council
Lab: 408 (42.1%) +9.2%
Con: 199 (20.5%) -3.0%
Ref: 196 (20.2%) -7.5%
Grn: 118 (12.2%) New
LDm: 49 (5.1%) New
Lab HOLD
The retirement of the Labour incumbent triggered this contest. He had served as a Rushmoor councillor on and off since 1976 and his successor scored an impressive hold for a party that is not used to expanding their vote share and moving further ahead of their rivals. An independent candidate who stood here in May did not stand this time. This area was historically a Conservative stronghold, but this all changed in 2024 when Labour took control of the council and won the local Aldershot Westminster constituency for the first time in history. Labour lost outright control of the council following several defections last year, but they remain the largest party and run it as a minority administration.
Karl - Ref GAIN ✘
Rich - Ref GAIN ✘
Himley & Swindon, South Staffordshire District Council
Con: 298 (43.2%) -21.0%
Ref: 187 (27.1%) New
Ind: 129 (18.7%) New
Lab: 28 (4.1%) New
Grn: 22 (3.2%) New
Ind: 16 (2.3%) -12.0%
LDm: 10 (1.4%) -20.0%
Con HOLD
Triggered by the death of the 82-year-old Tory incumbent, who had been council leader as recently as 2024. He was re-elected to this ward in 2023, having bested the only two other candidates - a Lib Dem and an independent. It was a much more crowded ballot paper this time and the votes were dispersed very thinly in this sparsely populated ward on the edge of the Black Country. The Conservatives managed to hold off Reform by more than 100 votes.
Karl - Con HOLD ✔
Rich - Ref GAIN ✘
Manor, Stafford Borough Council
Lab: 481 (36.2%) -19.6%
Ref: 414 (31.2%) New
Con: 237 (17.8%) -11.6%
Grn: 197 (14.8%) n/c
Lab HOLD
As with the previous seat, this was triggered by the death of the 82-year-old incumbent. The longstanding councillor had been re-elected most recently in 2023, when she topped the poll with both ward seats up for grabs. She and her Labour colleague easily saw off the Conservatives, while a solitary Green candidate collected the wooden spoon. The Greens finished last again this time, while there was a significant swing from both Labour and the Conservatives to Reform.
Karl - Ref GAIN ✘
Rich - Ref GAIN ✘
Richey has extended his lead further, with Karl suffering another poor performance. Karl has now dropped below the 50 per cent accuracy rate and at best can only close the gap next week as there are only five by-elections.