We had a big by-election this week in Greater Manchester, with Labour currently riding much higher in the polls than they have done in a long time. Once again, we were looking for evidence of a 'Burnham bounce', which so far has been pretty muted. That said, Labour's performance in by-elections has improved somewhat since Starmer's resignation.
There were no head-to-head forecasts again this week. Karl is now out of hospital, but bed bound and under strict orders to rest for a few more days. His full recovery is expected to last months.
Greater Manchester Mayor
(Lab defence)
This one needs little introduction, except to say that a certain opportunistic narcissist vacated the role two years into a four year term to take advantage of his party leader's self-inflicted troubles. Burnham's hunger for power has cost taxpayers around £5million to stage this by-election, which Labour is expected to win by a healthy margin. Their candidate is Bev Craig, the current leader of Manchester City Council. Raised on a Protestant estate in Belfast, she relocated to Manchester aged 18 in order to study politics and modern history. Unlike her predecessor, Craig held down some proper jobs before progressing into local government. She is an unabashed lesbian (no great surprise when you see her) and prides herself on being 'one of the most visible lesbians in politics', despite the fact no-one outside of Manchester had ever heard of her prior to this costly by-election.
This election uses the supplementary vote system. If no candidate achieves more than 50 per cent, there is a run-off between the top two candidates. Supplementary votes (second choice votes) are then added to the existing totals and the candidate with the most votes overall wins.
Burnham did not need a run-off in 2024, as he achieved 63 per cent on the first count. The second placed Conservative candidate was a whopping 351,803 votes behind. Reform finished fourth on that occasion, but they are strongly tipped to force a run-off this time. In the most recent More in Common poll, they were 20 points behind Labour on the first count and 30 points behind in the run-off.
A result here is not expected until Friday afternoon.
There were also five council by-elections, four of which were triggered by the deaths of the incumbents.
Rumworth, Bolton Metropolitan Borough Council
Ind: 1,458 (42.3%) New
Lab: 1,054 (30.6%) -4.6%
Grn: 517 (15.0%) -34.7%
Ref: 279 (8.1%) -1.7%
Con: 60 (1.7%) -0.8%
Ind: 45 (1.3%) New
LDm: 37 (1.1%) -1.8%
Ind GAIN from Lab
This ward has one of the highest concentrations of Muslims (primarily Pakistanis) in the UK. Its Muslim incumbent stepped down in order to take on other employment, triggering a diverse contest in which most of the candidates are either black or Asian - the exceptions being the Lib Dem, Green and one of two independents. Labour were defending the last of three seats they won here in 2023, having lost the other two seats already. The first one went to a Muslim independent in 2024, while the Greens triumphed here on May 7. The Greens slumped to third this time around, while Labour lost their last remaining seat in this ward to another Muslim independent.
Hedge End South, Eastleigh Borough Council
LDm: 1,086 (46.1%) +2.7%
Con: 589 (25.0%) +4.1%
Ref: 443 (18.8%) -8.2%
Grn: 199 (8.4%) -0.3%
Lab: 41 (1.7%) New
LDm HOLD
The death of the 72-year-old incumbent triggered this contest. The longstanding councillor died following an unspecified illness. Eastleigh is rock solid Lib Dem territory, a local authority they have controlled outright since 1994. They cemented this reputation in the borough by gaining both Westminster seats from the Conservatives in 2024. Hedge End is a growing town just to the east of Southampton, separated from the city by the M27 and a thin wedge of farmland. This was a routine hold for the Lib Dems, who finished with almost twice the number of votes as the second placed Conservatives. Just 41 votes and a wooden spoon for the Labour candidate!
Bro'r Llynnoedd, Isle of Anglesey County Council
Pld: 551 (48.5%) +13.8%
Ref: 446 (39.3%) New
Con: 93 (8.2%) -14.1%
Grn: 45 (4.0%) New
Pld HOLD
A sparsely populated ward on the island Welsh speaking locals call Ynys Môn. This contest was triggered by the death of the 71-year-old incumbent, who died suddenly from causes not made public. Plaid gained outright control on Anglesey in the 2022 local elections, but their numbers have dwindled since, through a series of defections and by-election losses. The council officially slipped into no overall control following a council by-election in February, which Plaid lost to Reform. There were no independent candidates this time, which both Plaid and Reform appear to have benefited from.
Long Sutton, South Holland District Council
Ref: 866 (56.3%) New
Con: 445 (28.9%) -20.7%
Grn: 227 (14.8%) New
Ref GAIN from Ind
This semi-rural ward includes the small market town of Long Sutton. Another 71-year-old perished in order to create the vacancy, again with no cause of death provided. He had topped the poll here in 2023, with one of the Conservative candidates winning the second seat. The Tories controlled South Holland from 2003 until last December, when a defection tipped the council into no overall control. They now run the council as a minority administration, but could have regained outright control had they won this seat. A significant swing to Reform denied them the opportunity. Despite its name and location, South Holland is actually located in the East Anglian county furthest from the Netherlands.
Great Dunmow North, Uttlesford District Council
Con: 705 (50.5%) +11.9%
Ref: 390 (27.9%) New
Ind: 138 (9.9%) -29.5%
Lab: 126 (9.0%) -3.3%
LDm: 37 (2.7%) -7.1%
Con GAIN from Ind
Yet another contest triggered by the death of the incumbent. The 77-year-old Residents for Uttlesford councillor passed away following a short illness. This local residents group ended a seven year stint of outright control on the council back in February, when two of its number defected to Reform UK. They remain at the helm, but as a minority administration. Had they won this by-election, they would have got back to within one seat of outright control, but as it happened they were overtaken by both the Tories and Reform.























































